THE MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS
A TOXI-INFECTIOUS DISEASE FROM BARRIER DEFECT
ABSTRACT
Reassessing the role of Bordetella toxins in inducing experimental
allergic encephalitis, revisited the pertussis physiopathology of newborn
from hyperimmune mother and the pathology from immune complexes, I searched
for anti-Bordetella antibodies in different groups of patients with Multiple
Sclerosis (MS).
The results demonstrate that in the 90 % of 40 patients with
chronic-evolutive MS, an infection by Bordetella Pertussis is taking place
and that in the 94,57 % of 92 MS-patients, not selected for clinic form,
there are abnormal levels of antipertussis antibodies in the serum.
This suggest that in MS:
- the environmental factor is Bordetella;
- the individual factor, sine qua non, is a muco-ciliar barrier defect;
- a specific antibiotic treatment is mandatory to stop the course of the
disease and prevent severe disability.
INTRODUCTION
Multiple Sclerosis (MS) epidemiology demonstrates that an environmental
factor (certainly an infective agent) and an individual factor intervene
in the disease onset ( see note 1 ). Experimental model of human MS is universally
considered the Experimental Allergic Encephalitis (EAE). The EAE is classically
induced by immunizing animals with spinal marrow homogenate, injected with
Freund`s complete adjuvant (FCA), and by administering intravenously, in
the same day of antigen inoculation and 48 hours later, killed Bordetella
( see notes 6, 7 ). In all the animals (mice, rats, rabbits, guineapigs, horses,
cows, rams), the effects of the intravenous injection of killed Bordetella
begin to manifest after a few hours and reach their climax within 3-5 days,
regressing slowly on the following 15 days ( see note 11 ). Bordetella (BB)
( see notes 11, 12. 13 ) include 4 main species: B.Pertussis, B.Parapertussis, B.Bronchiseptica
and B.Avium; they have a different geographical spreading; they are not
cross-reactive between them, therefore a subject immune to one type is
not immune to the others.
In the BB, the Fimbriae ( see note 14 ) (that, as vellus, cover all
the bacterium) on the free end bring the "adhesins", molecule of anchorage
to specific substrates, responsible even for hemoagglutination;
- the Lipopolysaccharide (LPS) fully covers the external membrane;
-
the toxin PT, or Lymphocytosis Promoting Factor (LPF), is an integral
part of the cell wall. B.Parapertussis and B.Bronchiseptica do not
produce LPF 15 (the producer gene is silent 54) .
The BB-toxins ( see notes 11, 16 ):
- with non-immunologic mechanism, irreversibly activate all the immunocompetent
cells;
- are the most powerful Thymus-indipendent aspecific polyclonal activator
that is known;
- trigger off the reaction between macrophages and T-helper lymphocytes
(gamma-interferon + 2-interleukin production);
- arm the macrophages;
- they interfere with transduction of membrane signals and with transmembrane
ionic fluxes of neuroepithelia (ependyma, astrocytes, oligodendrocytes);
by protracted action, they make T-lymphocytes and macrophages cytotoxic
towards allogenic, syngenic and of the same individual splenic cells (autocytotoxicity).
One of the toxins (the factor that sensitizes to histamine or HSF) is a
powerful inhibitor of granulocyte chemiotaxis. The substantial differences
among the various forms of EAE demonstrate that BB, injected intravenously
to induce EAE, do not act only as adjuvant; in a parallel and simultaneous
way, they perform three actions:
-
they stimulate the production of specific antibodies (normal immune response);
- with non immunologic mechanisms, they activate T-lymphocytes till they
become autocytotoxic, they arm macrophages (adjuvant action);
- BB-toxins + specific antibodies form ICC which, precipitating, offend
the haemato-encephalic barrier (peculiar action, sine qua non) and put
T-lymphocytes and macrophages in direct contact with the neural tissue:
a delayed hypersensitivity towards astrocytes, oligodendrocytes and myelin
springs up (see after).
To verify whether an etiopathogenetic correlation exists between BB and
MS, I looked for antipertussis antibodies in the serum of patients with
definite MS. In 9 patients with defined MS, direct micro agglutination
(DMA) with B.Pertussis turned out to be positive in 7 cases (77,8 %); in
28 subjects clinically healthy (controls), including blood relatives and
cohabitants of the patients, the DMA with B.Pertussis turned out to be
positive in 7 subjects (25 %) ( see note 18 ). In E.L.I.S.A. (Enzyme Linked
Immunosorbent Assay) , I found high titres of anti-BB IgG in the 50 %
of the patients, negative the 100 % of the checks (10 healthy adults, AVIS
blood donors) ( see note 18 ) . To confirm the etiopathogenetic correlation
between Bordetella Pertusis (BB) and Multiple Sclerosis (MS), I looked,
between May 1998 and November 1999, for antipertussis antibodies in many
patients with defined MS.
SUBJECTS - METHODS - RESULTS
I did not check healthy subjects as, in my preceeding research18, I
had found negative all the healthy controls and as in a research
( see note 19 ) on 3.875 healthy subjects, from 5 italian regions, in young
people from 17 to 19 years of age, in E.L.I.S.A., anti pertussis-toxin
IgG were absent in the 95 % of the cases.
1st group
In patients affected by definite chronic-evolutive MS (C-E MS), I could
search, in E.L.I.S.A., for the antibodies of the acute phase of pertussis
infection, that is anti filamentous haemoagglutinin (FHA) and anti pertussis-toxin
(PT) IgA. According to the quantity, specificity and class of the antibodies
found and in accordance with the interpretative scheme enclosed in the
diagnostic kit, the Laboratory ( see note 20 ) declares "absence of infection"
in the subjects with O.D. of anti-FHA and anti-PT IgA below 0.30 (characteristic
levels of children who have not contracted pertussis and have not been
vaccinated; normal levels in grown-ups after approximately ten years from
infantile pertussis); it mentions "taking place or very recent infection"
when at least one of IgA has O.D. equal or above 0.30. With this method
I studied 40 C-E MS patients: in 4 patients there was "absence
of infection" = 10 %; for 36 patients, the Laboratory spoke about
a taking place or very recent infection.
2nd group
In E.L.I.S.A., searching as well for the total amount of anti-Bordetella
IgG and IgM (besides anti-FHA and anti-PT IgA and IgG) with the formula:
[patient’s optic density / cut-off optic density] x 10 = VE
(extinction’s units), in 88 MS patients, not selected according to
their clinic form and treatment, asking to the Laboratory for the optic
density (O.D.) of the sample and of the cut-off, I found:
-
in 63 patients, taking place infection (68,48 %);
-
in 24 patients (negatives for anti-FHA and anti-PT IgA), abnormal titres
of total anti-BB IgM;
-
in 5 patients, absence of all the tested classes of antipertussis antibodies.
On the whole, I found pathological levels of anti-Bordetella antibodies
in the 94,57 % of the patients of this group.
DISCUSSION
Direct micro agglutination is given only by the intact bacterium: it
demonstrates recent contagion ( see note 11 ). IgG express a secondary
immune response to the systemic antigenic stimulus. The natural antipertussis
immunity (acquired with the infantile disease) is local, mucosal;
the IgA antibodies may intervene inhibiting the bacterial adhesion , but
the real immunity (protective) is cell-mediated and is characteristically
left, above all, to granulocytes (rather than to macrophages) ( see note 11 ).
In normal subjects, the antipertussis immunity, humoral and cell-mediated,
disappears after 10-15 years, and therefore, in adults there are few or
no antipertussis IgG. If the muco-ciliar barrier (MCB) is intact, reinfections
by BB remain a "surface disease" ( see note 21 ): the rapid reclamation of the
respiratory mucosa limits the production and the passage of toxins into
blood and there are not relevant systemic reactions. A genetic susceptibility
to MS has been connected 22 to an alteration of the gene for basic myelinic
protein (BMP) or of an adjacent locus, on chromosome 18. But chromosome
18 alterations or deletions have been repeatedly demonstrated associated
with an IgA deficit from a secretory gene defect ( see note 23 )
(lymphocytes regularly produce IgA, but they are not able to secrete them).
This genetic defect causes a deficit of secretory-IgA, therefore, a
defect of MCB, so, if a reinfectin from B. Pertussis occurs, there is a
protracted passage of pertussis toxins into blood and consequent systemic
effects. The great importance of MCB is confirmed by the observation that
24 while in European, North-American and Australian populations there
is one IgA deficit every 350-500 individuals; in Japan there is one IgA
deficit every 15000 individuals and Japan is the country less hit
by MS all over the world 1 . A MCB defect may be: primitive, secondary,
transient (viral infections), even only specific (lacking of specific IgA-S);
it may be sustained by inflammatory alterations of respiratory mucosae
(chronic sinusitis) 25 . In MS patients, the presence of agglutinant antibodies
(anti fimbrial antibodies) testifies a reinfection from BB taking place
or very recent; the presence of high titres of IgG (secondary immune response)
proves an abnormal (repeated or protracted) passage of pertussis toxins
in blood, therefore, a defect in MCB.
In MS, the first individual factor (sine qua non) is a muco-ciliar barrier defect.
The first manifestation of MS is very often an optic neuritis (ON);
but it is known that "temporary or permanent blindness is a very rare complication
of pertussis; it can be associated with signs indicating optic neuritis
and retinal ischaemia, or it can be secondary to cerebral damage
( see note 12 )". The optic nerve anatomy
( see note 27 ) explains its frequent involvement
in MS. In fact: the tortuosity of the ophtalmic artery and vein, the length
of the nerve and of its blood vasa (rather greater than the distance between
optic foramen and rear pole of the glene), the disposition of ciliary and
of retinal vasa, the path of the nerve in an inextensible canal (optic
canal), make the post-capillary venules of the optic nerve a vasal net
with very slow flow (ulteriorly slowed down by the movements of the glene,
during which the curves of the italic-S of the nerve narrow). In the ICC
precipitation we have ( see notes 28, 29 ): leucocytes and plasmocytes aggregation,
capillary necrosis, haemorrhages, anaphilotoxins and cytokines release;
in reply to the bacterial stimuli (LPS) and per cytokines action, the vasal
endothelium exposes the adhesion molecules 30 , which "hook" the fimbrial
adhesins, always associated 10 with the LPF pertussis toxin; infiltration
of ICC under the endothelium (that is, serious alteration of HEB) ( see notes 31, 32 ).
The initial lesion of the optic nerve is due to type III immunoreactions;
at the first moment at least there are no cell-mediated mechanisms.
Adhesion molecules ( see note 29 ) are normally generated by the vasal endothelium
in reply to bacterial stimulus (LPS) and/or per cytokines action. They
constitute "adhesion receptors" to which phagocytes "adhere", having become
"sticky" for chemiotactic stimulus. The quick transition from "adherence"
to "non-adherence" allows the immunocompetent cells to carry out the double
role of surveillance and reply (adherence) or non-reply (non adherence),
depending on local necessities. The adhesion receptors are expressed not
only by the immune system but also by other systems, including the CNS
( see note 30 ).
Adhesion molecules always intervene in the ICC precipitation; but, in
MS, the pathologic process is precipitated by the activation of the immunocompetent
cells operated by Bordetella toxins. Adhesion molecules are a physiologic
aspect of the type III immune reaction, that damages the HEB; they are
"effect", not "cause". About the role of astrocytes, I think it`s sufficient
to remember that in cerebral vasa the adventitia is not composed of connective
tissue but of astrocytes, that are therefore integral part of the vasal
wall. In MS the initial damage to haemato-encephalic barrier and to the
perivenous nervous tissue is due to ICC-BP precipitation into the small
cerebral vessels; only after these lesions, T-limphocytes and macrophages,
preliminarily activated and made autocytotoxic by Bordetella toxins, get
in touch with cerebral antigens; but, it is important to know that, if
lesions were not too much serious and if ICC production ceases, lesions
regress and they tend to disappear completely ( see note 29 ) (frequent
restitutio ad integrum, in O.N.). In MS, at patch level there
is an essentially peri-venular infiltration of lymphocytes, plasmocytes,
macrophages, immunoglobulins, immune complexes and Complement ( see note 33 );
Immune complexes circulating in serum and in liquor were described in more
than a half of MS patients 34. Endocerebral deposits of immune complexes
are easy to elute ( see note 35 ): they are not constituted by antibodies fixed
to cerebral tissue ( see notes 34, 35 ). To the periphery of
the patch there is a great afflux of CD8+ T-limphocytes; serum
has myelinotoxic activity; in presence of BMP or of cerebral antigens,
serumal and liquoral T-limphocytes undergo a blast transformation; cutaneous
tests for Koch-type hypersensitivity to BMP and to white human cerebral
substance are negative ( see note 33 ).
The only immune reaction which is compatible with all these findings
is Jones-Mote`s basophil, transient, delayed hypersensitivity
(J-M`s d.h.) ( see notes 36, 37 ). J-M`s d.h. can be transmitted either
by lymphocytes or by serum (myelin-toxicity in MS);
-
it gives a weak and transient cutaneous reaction (beginnig around the 8th
day and disappearing in 1-4 weeks, as soon as the antibodies titre rises);
-
it does not give nodes like the tuberculin reaction but simple erythema
(intradermo reaction negativity in MS);
-
it takes place in antigen site and it is characterized by the strong prevalance
of CD8+ T-lymphocytes;
-
after the first phase, which is essentially cell-mediated, it produces
antibodies in loco (this explains the intra-thecal IgG production and "the
abnormal intra-thecal immune activity", characteristics of MS).
J-M`s d.h. involves all the cells of specific and aspecific immunity (granulocytes,
lymphocytes, macrophages), but, as a rule, the only antigenic stimulation
is not sufficient to trigger off the reaction, a proemial or coincidental
activation of immunocompetent cells (adjuvant action) is necessary ( see notes 38, 39 );
in Man, lymphocytes can cross the HEB exclusively if activated.
In MS, liquoral elements are "large basophil cells", that is preliminary
activated lymphocytes. B.Pertussis toxins have a very strong adjuvant
power. The survival of B. Pertussis on respiratory mucosae is subordinated
to the passage from S-phase (1st generation colonies)
to R-phase (succeeding generations) with loss of virulence, reduced production
of many wall proteins and loss of agglutinant power. The bacterium, transformed
in this way, continues to produce above all LPS, a toxin which causes the
expression of adhesion molecules by the vasal endotheliums and has the
feature of inducing, as a secondary immune reaction, a protracted production
of IgM38.
In the 1st group, IgM came out to be positive in 18
cases and, in negative subjects in both immunoglobulin classes (14 cases),
the titre of IgM was almost always equal to or higher than the titre of
IgG. These results are peculiar 40 to IgM MS and, respectively,
to seronegative-MS (see after), that are serologic types of chronic-evolutive
MS (C-E MS); they demonstrate that in 32 out of 72 examined patients (not
selected) there was a secondary immune response from protracted endotoxic
stimulus (chronic infection). In the 2nd Group
(92 MS patients not selected by the clinical form of their disease, nor
by the pharmacologic treatment they were undergoing), searching for both
the antibodies of the acute phase of the pertussis infection (Anti-Filamentous
Haemoagglutinin and anti-Pertussis Toxins antibodies, stimulated specifically
by S-phase bacteria), and the total anti-B. Pertussis IgG and IgM, it has
been found that 63 patients (68,48 %) had antibodies from an infection
sustained by bacteria in S-phase; 29 patients (31,52 %) did not have antibodies
of the acute phase, but in 24 on 29 subjects (26,10 % of the total) there
were IgM at the same titre of that of IgG, or at titre a little bit lower,
demonstrating a taking place infection by R-phase Bordetella. In conclusions:
in 87 patients of the 2nd group (92 patients not selected by
the clinical form), that is in the 94,52 % of the cases, a taking place
infection by B. Pertussis has been demonstrated. The reported results
of serological tests demonstrate that:
the environmental factor of MS is constituted by Bordetella.
The possibility, often taken into consideration in literature, that
several infective factors concur to the origin of the disease, derives
from the ascertainment that in MS:
- one may find, in the same patient, high titres of serum and liquor antibodies
against several infective agents (above all viral agents);
-
post-infective relapses are commonly observed.
The presence in the same patient of high titres of specific antibodies
against several infective agents is easily accounted for by the strong
mitogenic and aspecific polyclonal activator power of Bordetella toxins.
No other pathogenic, bacterial or viral agent, has such an aspecific polyclonal
activator power which justifies the presence of high titres of anti-BB
antibodies; and even less so of antipertussis IgM, easily provable in the
chronic-evolutive forms. These remarks are valid as well for the
virus most recently "accused" ( see notes 41, 42, 43, 44 ): Coronavirus,
Herpes-virus 6, Epstein-Barr’s virus, HTLV-1, Theiler’s virus.
Besides, while the "Accusers" themselves textually assert that: "However,
no virus to date has been definitively associated with this disease ( see note 42 )"
and that "Thus, the hope of finding the virus that triggers
MS may remain elusive forever ( see note 43 )", today others authoritative Authors
( see notes 45, 46 ) formally deny the involvement of 6 Herpes-virus in MS
( implicitly excluding as well all the other known virus).
Post-infective relapses in MS do not express etiological plurality; they
attest that different environmental factors (in particular acute affections
of the respiratory system), interfering with the integrity of the muco-ciliar
barrier, favour the passage of pertussis toxins into blood and the consequent
MS relapse.
The clinical forms of the disease depends on the relationship that is
established between Bordetella and Host. The principal factors
related to BB are:
-
protracted survival or stable mucosa colonization;
-
bacterial transformation from S-phase to R-phase.
The individual factors consist on the type of MCB defect, on the validity
of the aspecific submucosa defence (chemiotaxis inhibition by HSF toxin),
on the astrocytes phenotype, producers or not producers of II class-HLA
antigens. About astrocytes I would like to remember that they play several
active roles in the mantenance of the normal cerebral phisiology:
-
They regulate the potassium balance in the extracellular space;
-
They have a ionic system for the transport and the exchange in pairs of
Na and H and of Cl and bicarbonate;
-
They contribute to the mantenance of the haemato-encephalic barrier integrity
(in small cerebral vessels the adventitia is constituted by astrocytes,
not by connective);
-
They perform the role of Antigen Presenting Cells (APC);
-
They produce interleukin-1 as an answer to phlogogenic stimulus.
On Astrocytes the presence of MHC molecules has been demonstrated: I and
II class Ag-HLA. But, among the same species: the astrocytes of some races
can produce II class Ag-HLA; the astrocytes of some other races cannot
produce them. It has been seen that the experimental allergic encephalitis
can be induced in Lewis Rats, whose astrocytes produce II class Ag-HLA;
it cannot be induced in Surmolotti (common water-rat), whose astrocytes
do not produce II class Ag-HLA ( see note 47 ). Bordetella
toxins interact with all the functions of astrocytes and oligodendrocytes.
The toxinic damage, the immunologic damage (armed macrophages and T-limphocytes,
activated and made autocitotoxic by LPS and LPF), and the chemical damage
(from lymphocytic and granulocytic factors, in particular: IL, TNF, IFN,
litic enzymes) arise in addition to the initial damage produced by the
ICC precipitation. Lately B-limphocytes, attracted and activated by limphokines
and stimulated by BB-toxins, locally produces immunoglobulins (intrathecal
production). In toxi-infections of Bordetella, the involvement of the astrocytes immunologic functions
contributes to explain the different clinical forms of the disease.
CONCLUSIONS
The Multiple Sclerosis is a toxi-infective disease from barrier
defect: the environmental factor is constituted by Bordetella;
the individual factors are the muco-ciliar barrier defect and the astrocytes
phenotype (II class Ag-HLA producers).
In individuals with a primitive or secondary MBC defect, after reinfection
by Bordetella, we can have ( see note 40 ):
MS with igg: transient passage of toxins into blood, delayed
reclamation of respiratory mucosa.. There is production of IgG and ICC,
which, precipitating trigger off an attack. In the free intervals anti-BB
IgG and average-low ICC levels are found in serum.This is the MS with
IgG, remittent.
MS with igm: colonization of mucosas (BB from S-phase to R and
L-phase); protracted passage of toxins into blood. LPS action prevails:
protracted IgM and ICC production; autocytotoxic T-lymphocytes, average-high
levels of ICC and/or anti-BB IgM (often, IgM > IgG) are found in blood;
ICC level and size, the elective tropism (fimbrial adhesins) and the anatomo-functional
peculiarities of cerebral circle (already mentioned) induce their periodic,
frequent precipitation. Because of the characteristics of Jones-Mote’s
hypersensitivity (cell-mediated reactivity stops when the titre of specific
antibodies increases) and of the cyclical inhibition of antibodies production
by ICC, there can be more or less long free intervals; also because of
spheroplasts reversibility to S-phase, the disease nourishes itself (MS
with IgM, chronic-evolutive with free intervals).
Seronegative-MS: In subjects with mucosa colonization by BB (heavy
vascular damages do not regress rapidly and completely), two conditions
are possible: a) new toxins and residue and/or neoformed
antibodies form immune complexes that immediatly precipitate into previous
cerebral lesions (anti-pertussis antibodies and ICC are not found in serum);
b) lacking antibodies, new toxins go and fix themselves to neuroepithelia
(elective tropism); with antibodies, also locally neoformed, they form
immune complexes where the lesion is. In seronegative
MS, the patches are always active; the T-lymphocites and the macrophages
are autocytotoxic. In serum, there are not ICC nor anti-BB antibodies at
positive levels for pertussis. The finding of IgM titre >=
4-5 VE, in any case higher than the one of IgG, is not always present but
indicative. This is the Seronegative-MS, chronic-evolutive without
free intervals.
If we don’t find anti-B Pertussis antibodies after general and local
(nasal aerosol) antibiotic treatment, considering that there isn’t cross-immunity
between the different species of BB, we should search for anti-B.Parapertussis
and for anti-B.Bronchiseptica antibodies. In fact:
- pertussis is usually referred to B.Pertussis;
- but in some geographical area (Mexico and Eastern Europe) the 17-30 % of the cases is caused B.Parapertussis
(frequent as well in Denmark ( see note 11 )), against which, in many regions, USA included, the most part of the population has specific antibodies circulating
( see note 48 ).
- In Western Europe, B.Pertussis prevails, but the 5-10% of the cases is due to B.Parapertussis;
- a lower percentage is caused by B.Bronchiseptica ( see note 15 ).
B.Bronchiseptica, discovered in dogs affected by distemper ( see note 11 ),
is found as well in many healthy animals (dogs, cats, rabbits, rats, monkeys,
horses; in pigs, healthy or affected by atrophic rhinitis) and can
infect Man through close contacts with those animals ( see notes 11, 13 ).
ETIOLOGICAL DIAGNOSIS AND DIAGNOSIS OF THE CLINICAL FORM
The pathognomonic diagnosis of MS and of its clinical form requires:
-
the searching for anti-FHA and anti-PT IgA and IgG;
-
the searching for total anti-BB IgG and IgM in E.L.I.S.A. (the Complement
Fixation Method is not very sensitive: there can be false negatives in
presence of CIC, of IgA, of endotoxins).
The amounts of IgG and of IgM which are present in the examined serum are
measured in spectrophotometrical units (absorbance or extinction values
= VE) using the formula [VE = (O.D. of the patient / O.D. of the cut-off)
x 10]; the O.D. of the sample and of the cut-off (calibrator serum, provided
in the diagnostic kit) has to be precised for both the classes of immunoglobulins
and, for pertussis, VE < 9 are considered to be "negative".
In MS we can find:
-
in the remittent forms (R-R), positive IgG and IgM with VE less then 4;
-
in the chronic-evolutive forms:
- positive IgG and IgM;
- only positive IgM;
- only positive IgG, but IgM are not over 4 VE units;
- both classes of immunoglobulins are "negative" but the level of IgM
is very closed to the one of IgG.
The presence of IgM is not consistent with a normal secondary immune
response, in which, as a rule, only IgG are produced; in the grown-up,
the anti-BB IgM express the peculiar response to a protracted stimulation
by the pertussis Lipopolysaccharide: they demonstrate a stable colonization
of the mucosa by Bordetella, that is a chronic-evolutive MS. Once the toxinic
stimulus has ceased, the IgG are still produced for some years, the IgM
for 4-5 months. The anti-FHA and anti-PT IgA decrease to a O.D. <= 0,30
in 7-8 months, only after this period the Laboratory will attest the "absence
of infection". After 4 months of treatment with erythromycin, to confirm
a reclamation of the mucosa: IgG will be unvaried or increased (those,
which before were absorbed into the CIC, become measurable); the IgM get
back to normal (VE less then 4).
TREATMENT
The MS specific etiological treatment is constituted by the protracted
administration of Erythromycine to reclaim rhino-sinusal mucosae from B.
Pertussis.
Naturally, the antibiotic treatment will stop the evolution of the
disease (it will not make the consolidated lesions regress), so the more
precociously it will start, the more effective it will be. The erythromycine
does not have any important contraindications or fusses, as it can be used
during pregnancy. At the beginning of the treatment, an aggravation of
the neurologic symptomatology is probable for the onset of a Jarisch-Erxheimer
reaction: the bacterial lysis involves an increase of toxaemia, an
increase of ICC containing pertussis toxins, the precipitation of these
ICC at the level of small cerebral vessels, the renewal of the MS disease.
This reaction may arise even 20-40 days after the beginning of the antibiotic
treatment; but the new lesions will completely regress adding some bolus
of cortisone to erythromycine, as if it were by all means an attack.
PROPHYLAXIS OF RELAPSES
In all cases, for the enormous diffusion of Bordetella, sooner or later
a reinfection, which is impossible to forecast, may occur.
In the patient who is undergoing an antibiotic treatment, the reinfecting
bacterial strength will not attach; the quantity of toxins will be small
and it will not be repeated in time; the patient may have a breakthrough
of the disease, but, also in this case, the new lesions will completely
regress after a few days of treatment with cortisone.
Once the mucosae are reclaimed, an effective prophylaxis of relapses
will be achieved following the same rules that are followed for the prophylaxis
of the rheumapyra in subjects allergic to penicillin: administering erythromycine
for years ( see notes 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54 ). «The optimal length
of the continuous antibiotic prophylaxis has not being determined yet.
Some Authors suggest to continue the prophylaxis "indefinitely", probably
for lifetime ( see note 54 )». In any case, «In patients who are
affected by the rheumatic disease without carditis after the age of 18,
a period of prophylaxis at least of five years is recommended ( see note 55 )».
If, in the prophylaxis of the rheumatic disease, even without carditis,
the erythromycine is to be administered for several years, the same can
be and is to be done to prevent the severe disability so often caused by
MS. In presence of chronic nasosinusitis (very frequent and often ignored),
thiamphenicol per nasal aerosol (15-20 days) can be associated to the macrolide
per os. Beta lactamics are inadvisable, because they facilitate BB transformation
in R-forms and in spheroplasts ( see note 56 ).
THANKS
The anti-Bordetella antibodies investigation I mentioned here, was done by Ospedale Civile "San Salvatore"
of Pesaro laboratory. I want to thank for the relevant cooperation:
- the Executive Unit manager, Dr. Gabriele Rinaldi;
- the Serology and Immunology Department manager, Dr. Marcello Acetoso who took care of the investigations;
- the Laboratory's technicians for the competence and availability
- the Administrative and Chief Surveyor's Office staffs
BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Rosati G.-Granieri E.: Manuale di Neuroepidemiologia Clinica.
N I S Ed., Roma. 1990. 143-182.
- Tavolato B. - Gallo P. : Sclerosi Multipla: aggiornamenti
sulla immunopatogenesi. "Bollettino" dell’Ordine dei Medici di Padova.
1996. 5. 26-28.
- La Placa M.: Principi di Microbiologia Medica. Esculapio
Ed.. Milano. 1995. 158.
- Roitt I.M.: Principi di Immunologia. Poli Ed. 1993.
302-314
- Zinkernagel R.M.: Virus e malattie autoimmuni. "Le
Scienze" , 1997, n° 350, 38-39.
- Waldor M.F. et Altri.: Reversal of Experimental Allergic
Encephalomyelitis with Antibody to T-cell subset Marker. Science. 1985,
Vol 222, 415-417.
- Waisman A. et Altri: Suppressive vaccinati on with
DNA encoding a variable region gene of the T-cell receptor prevents
autoimmune encephalomyelitis and activate Th2 immunity. Nature Medicine.
1996,Vol. 2, 891-895.
- Escourolle R.-Hauw J.J.: Enéphalomyélite
Allergique Expérimentale. in, Charpin J.: Allergologie. Flammarion,
Paris. 19804, 72-479 (477).
- Kimelberg H.K. - Noremberg M.D.: Gli Astrociti. "Le
Scienze", Anno XXII, N° 25, 6/1989, 54-62.
- Bach J-F.: Immunologie. Flammarion, Paris. 1986,
715.
- Michel-Briand Y.: Bordetella. in Le Minor L.-Veron
M.: Bacteriologie Medicale.. Flammario. Paris 1982. 461-473.
- Christie A.B.: Malattie Infettive. "Il Pensiero Scientifico"
Ed. Roma. 1971, 444-464.
- Nicoletti G. - Mar Nicolosi V. : Dizionario di batteriologia
umana normale e patologica. Momento Medico Ed.,Salerno. 1998, 53-55.
- La Placa M.: Principi di Microbiologia Medica. Esculapio
Ed.. Milano, 1995. 54-55.
- Fleigin R.D. - Cherry J.D. : Trattato di infettivologia
pediatrica. Centro Scientifico Ed. Torino. 1993, 1367 (1365-1375).
- Montecucco C.- Rappuoli R. - Tomasi M. : Tossine
batteriche a bersaglio intracellulare. "Aggiornamento Medico". 1996,
10,3.
- Fiore D.: Fisiopatologia dell’encefalopatia pertussica.-
XXVI Congr. Naz. Soc. Ital. Malattie Infettive e Parassitarie. S.Flavia
(PA) 1991. 110. - XIX Congr. Naz. Soc. Ital. Neuropediatria. Bologna
1993. 165.
- Fiore D.: Sclerosi Multipla; anticorpi anti-Bordetelle,
loro tipizzazione immunoenzimatica, implicazioni eziopatogenetiche Bollettino
dell`Ordine dei Medici di Padova. 1988, 4. 19.
- Vierucci A. et Altri: Le vaccinazioni in Pediatria.
CX.S.H. Editrice, Milano 1993. 203.
- Unità Operativa di Laboratorio Analisi Chimico-Cliniche
e Microbiologiche - Ospedale Civile di Pesaro (Italia).
- Davis B.D.-Dulbecco R.-Ginsberg H.S.: Microbiology.
Harper, 1990, 698-701.
- Tienari P.J. et Altri : Genetic susceptibility to
multiple sclerosis linked to myelin basic protein gene. The Lancet.
1992, 340. 987.
- Tassi G.C.-Sertoli A. : Allergologia applicata e
immunologia. Il Pensiero Scientifico Ed., Roma. 1984, 75-99.
- Dormont J. et Altri : Le 365 Nuove Malattie. Delfino
Ed., Roma. 1991, 118.
- Lucchesi M. et Altri: Immunologia e Immunopatologia
del Polmone. Il Pensiero Scientifico Ed., Roma 1980, 73-174.
- Coates A.R.M. - BellJ.: HHV-6 and Multiple Sclerosis.
Nature Medicine. 1998, Vol 4, N 5,.357-358.
- Testut L .: Anatomia Umana. UTET. Torino. 1942, VI,
42-49.
- Bombardieri S.-Vitali C. : Malattie da immunocomplessi.
in Dammacco F.: Immunologia in Medicina. edi.ermes. Milano. 1989, 592-594
e 598.
- Benveniste J.: Pathologie Experimentale des complexes
immuns. in Bach J-F.: Immunologie. Flammarion, Paris. 1986, 731-734.
- Ricciardi-Castagnoli P.: Il Sistema Immunitario.
N I S Ed. Roma 1992. 147-150, 170-171.
- Ferrarini M. - Grossi C.E.: Immunologia Medica. edi-ermes.
Milano. 1986, Vol II, 296-304.
- Bach J.F. - Le Savre P.: Immunologia. Marrapese DEMI.
Roma. 1981, 181-187.
- Confavreux Ch.: Sclerose en placques. La Presse Medicale:
1984, 15, 1889-1894.
- Livrea P.: Sclerosi Multipla. in Bonomo L.: Immunologia
Clinica. UTET, 1984, 484-499.
- Tavolato B.: Immunoglobulin G distribution in Multiple
Sclerosis Brain. Journal of neurological sciences., 1975, 24, 1-11 9.
- de Weck A.L: Hypersensibilité retardeée.
in Charpin J.: Allergologie. Flammarion, Paris. 1980, 126-132.
- Bach J.F.: Immunologie. Flammarion, Paris. 1986,
473-474, 477, 485, 491-492.
- Ferrero M.E.: Manuale di Immunopatologia. Ferro Ed.,
Milano 1991. 159-160.
- Ricciardi-Castagnoli P.: Il Sistema Immunitario.
N I S , Roma. 1992,191-193.
- Fiore D.: Multiple Sclerosis: Microbiology, serology,
treatment. Abstracts of XVI World Congress of Neurology. Buenos Aires
1997 - Argentina. Supplement to Vol. 150 of Jurn. of Neurological Sciences.
4-31-05.
- Cereda P.M. - Benati l. - Cristallo A.: Sequenza
di RNA di Coronavirus umani in CSF di pazienti SM. G. I. M. M. O. C.
1997, I, n° 1 ,. 24.
- Soldan S. S. et Altri : Association of human herpes
virus 6 with multipla sclerosis. Nature Medicine - 1997, Vol 3, n°
12. 1394-1397.
- Haahr S. et Altri : Cluster of multiple sclerosis
patients from Danish community. The Lancet; 1997, 349: 923.
- Miller S.D. et Altri : Persistent infection with
Theiler’s virus leads to CNS autoimmunity via epitope spreading. Nature
Medicine, 1997, Vol 3, n° 10. 1133-1136.
- Fillet A-M. et Altri: HHV-6 and Multiple Sclerosis.
Nature Medicine. 1998, Vol 4, N 5,.357-358.
- Coates A.R.M. - BellJ.: HHV-6 and Multiple Sclerosis.
Nature Medicine. 1998, Vol 4, N 5,.357-358.
- Kimelberg H.K.- Noremberg M.D.: Gli Astrociti. Le
Scienze. Anno XXII. Vol XLII, No 25, 6/1989. 54-62.
- Hewlett E.L: Pertussis. in Warren K.S. - Mahmoud
A.A.F.: Tropical and Geografical Medicine. McGraw-Hill, 1984, 816-817.
- Paradisi F. : Terapia delle Infezioni. UTET 1992.
Macrolidi: 84, 88, 18, 9-10, 30-31, 35, 41.
- Paradisi F. : Terapia delle Infezioni. UTET 1992.
244-245.
- Bollettino di Farmacovigilanza. Masson. n° 4,
1995. 1-2.
- Venturi e Altri: La Malattia Reumatica: studio retrospettivo
di una casistica degli ultimi 20 anni. La Ped. Med. e Chir. 1995. Vol
17. 37-39.
- Hurst J.W.: Medicina Clinica per il Medico Pratico.
Masson-Dompè. 1991. 1200-1201.
- Mandel - Douglas - Bennett: Malattie infettive ad
eziologia batterica. Churhill Livingstone - Momento Medico. 1999. 49-50
- Harrison : Principi di Medicina Interna. McGraw-Hill
Italia. Milano 1995. 1198..
- Le Minor L. - Véron M.: Bactériologie
Médicale. Flammarion, Paris 1982. 766.
|